symphony review

Marin Symphony / October 9, 2007
The Battleship Potemkin

Battle Ready

By Terry McNeill

The Marin Symphony launched its 55th season with a nearly impossible task — keep a full house at the Marin Civic Center concentrating on the music from the stage during a simultaneous screening of the famous film The Battleship Potemkin. But it worked on Tuesday, thanks to generous portions of at least four Shostakovich symphonies that sustained the silent movie masterpiece by Soviet director Sergei Eisenstein.

The film, which depicts a 1905 on-ship rebellion of Russian sailors and the revolt’s ill-fated support from the citizens of the port city of Odessa, has had several musical scores appended since its release in 1925, the last being the pastiche from Shostakovich in 1976, a year after his death. But what a pastiche — the greatest of 20th-century symphonists built a sonic structure of immense power and orchestral splendor. The 75-minute adventure combined big sections of the Fourth, Fifth, Tenth, and Eleventh Symphonies with surprisingly sharp black-and-white footage to achieve a potent, arctic whole that brought the house to its feet, albeit somewhat drained from the experience.

Scene from The Battleship Potemkin

Conductor Alasdair Neale, in his seventh year on the podium, led a taught performance of the large forces assembled. The horn section particularly shone during the battle scenes. The Fifth Symphony (1937) dominated early in the film, and a personal favorite, the Mahlerian Fourth (1936), was heard in the atmospheric cinema parts in which mists settle over the warship. Eisenstein’s renowned Odessa dock scene, where Cossacks massacre terrified citizens fleeing down a seemingly endless broad staircase, found its parallel in Shostakovich’s “Tocsin” (alarm signal) from the finale of the Eleventh Symphony (1957). Here Neale built a formidable deluge of sound, juxtaposing a resounding march with drums and chimes in G minor while the rest of the orchestra remained in G major.

It was a frightening moment, as the palpable horror on the citizen’s faces was perfectly mirrored in the music. Particularly striking were the haunting clarinet playing of Arthur Austin and solos by principal horn Meredith Brown, at the point in the film where the Czarist fleet approaches the rebellious battleship.

In the end, the Symphony’s “Season of the Silver Screen” theme was well-served by a master cinematic director, a commanding composer, and the consummate playing of the Marin musicians.


Santa Rosa resident Terry McNeill produces classical piano recitals in the three-county Concerts Grand series, and he is currently researching the lives and artistry of keyboard titans Anton Rubinstein and Josef Hoffmann.

©2007 By Terry McNeill, all rights reserved.

Post a Comment

By posting, you agree to abide by SFCV's Code of Conduct and Terms of Service.

Alasdair Neale


More Reviews

contemporary music

Sight and Sound

By Michelle Dulak Thomson

The imaginative BluePrint series blasts off again at the San Francisco Conservatory of Music.

opera

Small Company, Grand Passion

By Janos Gereben

West Bay Opera knocks it out of the park in a Cav/Pag doubleheader.

contemporary music

Two Pianists, One Voice

By Benjamin Frandzel

In a benefit concert for the Other Minds Festival, the duo of Dennis Russell Davies and Maki Namekawa produce a singular expression of sound.

early music

Bach Back in Another Guise

By Rebekah Ahrendt

The many faces of Bach were on display in the deft hands of Angela Hewitt and Daniel Müller-Schott.

opera

Vivid New Magic Flute

By Anna Carol Dudley

San Francisco Opera offers a beguiling take on the Mozart classic.

chamber music

Subtle Beethoven, Comic Adams

By David Bratman

The St. Lawrence String Quartet trade places in a eclectic and effective performance.

symphony

Savoring Saint-Saëns

By Heuwell Tircuit

Pianist Ingrid Fliter and organist Jonathan Dimmock join the San Francisco Symphony under the baton of Roberto Abbado.

contemporary music

Reveling in Contradiction

By Jason Victor Serinus

Philip Glass' Book of Longing song cycle succeeds on its own terms.

symphony

Smiling Through Wayfaring Planets

By Terry McNeill

Santa Rosa Symphony displays absolute control under conductor Bruno Ferrandis.

symphony

Battle Ready

By Terry McNeill

Marin Symphony warms up Eisenstein's silent film The Battleship Potemkin.

contemporary music

Wealth of Duos at Mills

By Jules Langert

Graeme Jennings and Christopher Jones explore the world of influences in Darius Milhaud.

more...