sfcv logo

OPERA

A Splendid Array

December 10, 2004

Katherine Rohrer


Lucas Meachem


Photos by
Ken Friedman

E-mail this page

By Heuwell Tircuit

Skimming the cream of the international crop for young vocalists, the 2004 Adler Program of the San Francisco Opera presented eight operatic hopefuls Friday evening in Herbst Theater, replete with the SFO's orchestra in full array. The results were often astounding, as these experienced young singers sailed through some of opera's demanding excerpts with nary a glitch. All sounded ready to tread the boards of the world's stages right now.

Mark Morash conducted a varied program that contained only one genuinely standard aria, bass Joshua Bloom as Verdi's King Philippe from Don Carlo, singing it as “Elle ne m'aime pas!” (She doesn't love me) in the original French rather than the more usual Italian. Soprano Jane Archibald opened the event with Mozart's flashy “Martern aller Arten” from Abduction from the Seraglio, followed by baritone Lucas Meachem in Bellini's ”Ah, dove fuggo io mai?” from I Puritani. Then mezzo-soprano Katherine Rohrer sang the delightful “Dieu! que viens-je d'entendre?” from Berlioz' Béatrice et Bénédict, followed by coloratura Nikki Einfeld tearing the house down with Zerbinetta's madcap “Grossmächtige Prinzessin” from Strauss' Ariadne auf Naxos. One needed the intermission to get a grip on what one had heard.

But there was more. Part two opened with Bloom's Verdi, followed by tenor Thomas Glenn eerie rendering of “Miles!” from Britten's Turn of the Screw, bass-baritone Ricardo Herrera singing Aleko's Cavatina from Rachmaninoff's opera of the same name, and another major highlight as soprano Karen Slack sang the finale of Strauss' Capriccio — supported by a terse insert from bass Bloom as the Major Domo, “Madam Countess, dinner is served.” That seemed especially appropriate after such a feast.

Good start

All these singers have appeared in opera around the country and venues around the Bay Area, including the various programs of the SFO: The Merola Program, Western Opera Theater as well as supporting roles in the company's major productions. An interesting aspect of this batch is that three of the eight — Archibald, Einfeld and Glenn — are Canadians, while Bloom is Australian. On the other hand, it's one of the few recent Adler years with no Asian vocalists in the mix.

Soprano Slack, from Philadelphia, possesses the ideal lyrical musicality for a Strauss role. The voice is crystal clear, yet with that smooth nuance of the sort heard from a Schwarzkopf or Te Kanawa. Her performance has major career stamped all over it. Much the same was true of Einfeld's racing around Strauss' cruel Zerbinetta aria, which she tossed off, seemingly without effort.

Tenor Glenn, as the ghost of Peter Quint trying to steal the soul of the boy Miles, created an almost frightening effect. He managed every little menace with a bell-clear diction. Every last syllable shone out. Britten's skillful writing no doubt helped. Also memorable was the opposite, Bloom's dark and burly presentation of King Philippe's anguish. Both gentlemen proved terrific sonic actors, coloring the emotions without resorting to stage business distractions.

An ear-opener

Baritone Meachem, given the nature of his Italian excerpt, did visually act out his Bellini Aria, adding minute dynamic shifts. The little spark of military music near the close was particularly effective. Bass-baritone Herrera's incredible stage dignity of voice and manner for the Cavatina from Aleko was moving and revelatory. It's not an aria nor indeed an opera that one would encounter, but Herrera made such an impressive case for it that I find myself wondering . . .

For sheer glitter and panache, it would be hard to top Mezzo-soprano Rohrer's Berlioz. The composer's only comedy, Béatrice et Bénédict was his sole major operatic success during his lifetime, though today the least staged of his three completed operas. Rohrer's focus and convivial charms seemed ideal for the role. This was a high point.

Constanza's big show-stopper Aria is Mozart at his best, involving an I-dare-you breadth of rages. Soprano Archibald managed it admirably. While generally musical, she occasionally forced some of the high-register segment, sacrificing timbre for volume. That's not necessary. The music is flashy enough as is.

The full house cheered everything to the echo, for good cause. With the orchestra playing up to its normally high standards, under Morash's able baton — such fun repertory, so many selections and so much musical craftsmanship on display — one only wished they could repeat the whole thing for more folks to experience.

(Heuwell Tircuit, composer, performer and writer, was chief writer for Gramophone Japan and for 21 years a music reviewer for the SF Chronicle, previously for the Chicago American and Asahi Evening News.)

©2004 Heuwell Tircuit, all rights reserved