|
CONTEMPORARY MUSIC REVIEW
Ensemble Parallèle S.F. Conservatory New Music Ensemble Nicole Paiement
November 18, 2006
Nicole Paiement
|
Worlds Within Sound-Worlds By Michelle Dulak Thomson
Nicole Paiement’s BluePrint New Music Project presented its second program Saturday at San Francisco’s Old First Church. Like the season opener last month, this program, titled “Volupté,” brought together music of such different sound-worlds that the listener was left dizzy trying to tease out the evening’s commonalities. Sensual pleasures there were, indeed, but of wildly various kinds from work to work. In the end, it seemed best to trust the commonalities that are ever assured in this series: Paiement’s ear, together with the excellent work of her San Francisco Conservatory students and of the (professional) Ensemble Parallèle.
Darius Milhaud’s 15th Quartet, from 1948-1949, is (among other things) 50 percent of a string octet. It and the 14th Quartet are fashioned so as to be playable either separately or simultaneously. The exigencies of that compositional challenge made for an attractively airy texture, unlike the typical Milhaud piece that’s determinedly crammed full of incident. This is all to the good, particularly since the quartet is also one of his sunniest. It has its darker touches, like the sudden, brusque chords that keep interrupting the first movement, although the general effect is one of elegant amiability.
The brief slow movement is a lovely thing, beginning and ending with the three upper instruments gliding together in high, serene counterpoint, seeming rootless. By contrast, the finale is exuberantly noisy, in one of the composer’s most endearing veins. The ad hoc string quartet for Saturday’s concert (violinists David Southorn and Hyewon Kim, violist Stephen Fine, and cellist Kathryn Bates) gave a beautifully judged performance, transparent and nonchalantly graceful in a way that Milhaud’s wide-ranging string writing makes deceptively difficult to bring off.
Southorn returned in the second half as the violin soloist in Uzbek composer Dmitri Yanov-Yanovsky’s 1997 Lux aeterna, for violin and 14 players. The solo part, rich in glissandi and double-stopping, moves over and through an intricate, often frenetic instrumental texture. Southorn’s account of the solo line was eloquent and admirably secure, seeming to bring the wildly varied elements of the surrounding music into focus around it. Three songs from Gavin Bryars’s Adnan Songbook of 1996 followed the Milhaud on the first half. They proved to be extremely economical in conception: direct, unforced vocal settings of Lebanese poet Etel Adnan’s terse texts, sparsely accompanied and harmonized with great simplicity. The dusky instrumental ensemble two violas, cello, bass, bass clarinet (doubling clarinet), and acoustic guitar did little more than discreetly underlie Brittany Hicks’s cool, clear soprano. The music was oddly haunting but disturbingly insubstantial, with little for the ear to take hold of, beyond the harmonious timbres and the slightly abstracted emotional tone. It made this listener curious to know what the remainder of the cycle is like. The three songs given Saturday all come from the second half of the set. The first (which, among other things, uses electric rather than acoustic guitar) may contain a wider range of moods.
BluePrint’s entire 2006-2007 season is liberally sprinkled with world premiere performances of commissioned works, and Saturday night brought two of them. Bruce Mather’s Music for San Francisco, for oboe, horn, harp, piano, violin, viola, and cello, received its first performance from Ensemble Parallèle under Paiement’s direction. The work, an outgrowth of an earlier piece for oboe and harp, is much concerned with the possibilities of quarter-tones. The harp is so tuned as to be able to play familiar triads with one pitch of each shifted downward by a quarter-tone, and these collections become the basis for the bulk of the piece’s harmonic language. The melodic lines, too, are quarter-tone-obsessed, returning again and again to an oscillation between one pitch and another a quarter-tone up or down from it. This is the main material of the piece, interrupted at intervals by a much faster, skittering, quarter-tone-free music led by the piano. Despite the obvious care with which the players (not only the strings, but oboe and horn, as well) gave to tuning the microtonal increments, the effect still seemed a little queasy, the sense of unease not being helped by the music’s ambiguous trajectory. The piece seemed to explore its chosen territory lovingly but narrowly, and to return on itself repeatedly, to mysterious purpose. It was most interesting, yet puzzling. Jacques Desjardins writes that his Volupté, whose concert-ending premiere gave its title to the entire program, is about the layers of sensory experience and the mind’s contemplation of these layers. Certainly there was plenty of immediate sensory experience to be enjoyed. Desjardins allowed himself a colorful ensemble (piano, percussion, and small groups of strings, woodwind, and brass, including a prominent tenor sax), and made the most of it. Often the various instrumental choirs were played off one another in abrupt rhythmic-unison lines that sent the aural interest veering moment-to-moment from one choir to the next. Striking, rhapsodic solos emerged periodically from the heady density of the texture. (One especially eloquent quasicadenza for the bassoon earned its player a justifiable solo bow; I do not, unfortunately, know which of the evening’s two bassoonists to credit.) The whole was vivid, alive, and clearly fun to play. One of the outstanding features of BluePrint since its inception has been the steady stream of pieces for such large, colorful ensembles as these pieces that, for logistical reasons, are unlikely to be often performed outside of such a series. I hope that Nicole Paiement will consider returning to some of these works in future years, especially those written for the BluePrint Project. She and her ensembles are on their way to assembling a fine, impressively varied repertory. (Michelle Dulak Thomson is a violinist and violist who has written about music for Strings, Stagebill, Early Music America, and The New York Times.)©2006 Michelle Dulak Thomson, all rights reserved |