CHAMBER MUSIC REVIEW

Music with Momentum

January 30, 2005


E-mail this page

By Jeff Rosenfeld

“Bait and switch” was the theme of the week for contemporary music fans. First, on Tuesday, the Juilliard Quartet could not perform Elliott Carter's Oboe Quartet, and their guest soloist filled in with other pieces. Then for Sunday's concert, the Broderick Ensemble had promised a Colin Matthews Oboe Quartet (the brochure didn't say which one) but ended up playing Beethoven's String Trio Op. 9, No. 1 instead. Instead, the closest thing to contemporary at the Broderick's concert at Old First Church was Bohuslav Martinu's Three Madrigals for violin and viola. Fortunately, that performance also epitomized everything that was truly satisfying about the concert as a whole.

Violinist Laura Albers and violist Elizabeth Prior-Runnicles were perfectly matched in tone and dynamics in their duo. In the opening “poco allegro-poco vivo” — music as relentless as the first movement of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony — they drove the music with controlled tempi and precise articulation, without ever sounding too insistent or muscular. The sonority of the second madrigal was more covered, resplendent yet otherworldly, and the security of their rhythms and interplay in the prancing last madrigral built wave upon wave of full-blooded resonance in the church. In all, Albers and Prior-Runnicles displayed superb discipline and confident virtuosity, making an extraordinary sound with all the requisite clarity.

The three madrigals have a meaningful origin in Martinu's oeuvre, being a gesture both back to ancient European village music and to the inspired purity of his beloved neoclassicism. In fact, a performance of Mozart's duos for the same instruments supposedly inspired the Czech émigré to compose the work. So it was fitting that Mozart himself fared well in Sunday's concert. Albers and Prior-Runnicles were joined by cellist Sarah Hong and oboist Liang Wang in the Oboe Quartet, K. 370.

Liang Wang (top)
Broderick Ensemble

The strings gave this performance a solid underpinning, but ultimately this was Wang's show. The 24-year-old principal of the San Francisco Ballet orchestra was half turned toward the audience, instead of his colleagues, and played with a gorgeously full sound — bright but warm with a husky undercoat that immediately reminds the ear of his mentor at the Curtis Institute, Richard Woodhams. Equally impressive was Wang's reliably fluid fingerwork and superb intonation. His playing humbled every challenge in this taxing work.

The Mozart, like the Martinu, was virtuosic but also engaging because of its subtly modulated sonorities. With quick tempi in the outer movements and a lovely, flowing middle aria featuring superb breath control and seamless phrasing in a warmly felt arc of sound, the music felt natural and comfortable with Wang's lead. He exuded a liveliness but directness that works perfectly in this upbeat Mozartian display.

When Wang returned for the three Romances (Opus 94) of Robert Schumann, the naturalness of his musicality emerged even more clearly, but he missed some of the potential of this deceptively simple music. The third Romance, for instance, was particularly lively, and opened with some perfect unisons — including beautifully judged hesitations — with accompanist Ji-Eun Kang. However, everything seemed just a little too fast in the notes that followed — great for emphasizing the requisite songfulness of the music, but occasionally hurrying it. Wang achieved the requisite simplicity, especially in the second romance (marked “simple, inward”), but the music can wax and wane better — it can converse. For instance, Wang didn't employ the beautiful sotto voce of his quiet tone often enough. These were pure and simple Romances, nuanced and resonant, but “wordless.”

Trio for Two

The Beethoven substitution in fact turned out to be the major work on the program, lengthwise, but part of that time passed less viscerally than necessary because Prior-Runnicles' viola (often admittedly secondary parts) was too recessed to balance her colleagues and fill out the harmonic profile. The music often sounded like it was reduced to two parts. Albers and Hong, however, traded pointed staccatos in the first movement that kept things moving, and everyone contributed memorably sweet moments to sustain the second movement cantabile. The finale — surely a proto-Mendelssohnian scamper if there ever was one — was as effervescent as one could hope, thriving on Hong's solid bass line.

Once again, discipline, sonority, and momentum were the Broderick Ensemble's greatest friends. It seems unlikely that the Matthews quartet, or any other work, would have changed that.

(Jeff Rosenfeld is an oboist with the Kensington Symphony, West County Winds, and Pacific Wind Ensemble. He is a freelance science journalist and author of the recent book, Eye of the Storm: Inside the World's Deadliest Hurricanes, Tornadoes, and Blizzards.)

©2005 Jeff Rosenfeld, all rights reserved