CHAMBER MUSIC REVIEW

Eos Ensemble

July 9, 2006

E-mail this page

French Delights

By Heuwell Tircuit

An all-French program with some snazzy harp playing featured on the Eos Ensemble's concert Sunday afternoon in Old First Church. As an additional bonus, the three works that had been originally announced were expanded to a program of four, including an outstanding performance of Ravel's only string quartet.

The afternoon opened with Albert Roussel's Flute Trio, Op. 40, played by flutist Julie McKenzie, violist Craig Reiss, and cellist Ruth Lane. This was followed by the more famous Debussy's Danses sacrée et profane for harp and strings, plus Ravel's Introduction and Allegro, for harp and flute, clarinet, and strings. Michael Rado, harpist for the San Francisco Opera and Ballet, soloed in both of those, before the Eos Quartet closed with Ravel's Quartet in F Major, this time headed by violinist Reiss, who had switched over from viola.

Roussel seems to be a nearly forgotten composer these days, as indeed is the fate of most of his contemporaneous French colleagues, Les Six: Louis Durey, Darius Milhaud, Arthur Honegger, Georges Auric, Germaine Talleferre, and Francis Poulenc — Poulenc being the principal exception to this neglect. Roussel is the oddest case among them, for, like Rimsky-Korsakov, he began his career as a naval officer, only seriously taking up composition in his thirties. Perhaps that gave him a certain seriousness of mind that helped him stand apart from "The Six," whose principal goal was to further the aesthetics of Eric Satie.

The three-movement trio is typical Roussel, as light as a divertimento but never merely frivolous. Set in concertante style, a texture of three equal partners, it really is not a piece for a solo flutist with two strings. The central slow movement, for instance, consists of a fairly long opening passage with no flute participation at all; and the longest, highest passage features the cellist, who plays the high top melody as the flute and viola support it from their lowest registers. The finale is actually in scherzo form rather than the expected rondo: a perpetual motion, a lyrical second section, and a return to the opening whirligig. These and other such quirks mark the 15-minute trio as an original series of concepts, serious even when lightly brilliant.

Harp vs. harp

The two harp works, by contrast, are indeed soloistic compositions — in effect, mini harp concertos. But whereas the monothematic Ravel is typically virtuosic in nature, Debussy's two dances are entirely given to pastel picture painting. He borrowed some elements from the obscure Portuguese composer Francisco de Laceda (1869-1934), whose piano music delved into Portuguese folk sources. Danses is often mistaken as having a Greek influence, but if that's so, both Laceda and Debussy were influenced by dreams of an ancient Greece. The second dance is, on the other hand, definitely a waltz of the relaxed sort popular in late 19th and early 20th century France.

Pleyel, the French piano firm, commissioned the Debussy dances to illustrate the virtues of its then new chromatic harp, which had all 12 notes of the chromatic scale. That eliminated the need for pedals to change the chromatics when a piece shifted keys. Pleyel dabbled in assorted instrumental experiments during the early 20th century: a more brilliant type of harpsichord for Wanda Landowska; and mechanical instruments of several types, not least the player piano and piano rolls. The company even made the earliest piano rolls of Stravinsky playing his own orchestral music from the keyboard — and quite well, too. The catch is that having a chromatic harp rendered the harp glissandi, so dear to Impressionist composers, impossible. Therefore it quickly fell into disuse. (Too bad, for that would have spared us the sound that composer Roger Sessions famously dubbed "harp vomit.")

Thus Debussy's 1903 Danses contain no glissandi, whereas Ravel's piece — commissioned by the rival harp manufacturer Erard, seeking to retain the traditional harp mechanism — is overloaded with glissandi. The harpist keeps sliding his fingers up and down the strings like a cat on a skateboard over ice. In that sense, these two most frequently programmed harp works are as much about the harp as for it.

Ravel performance excels

Ravel's two-part Introduction and Allegro is also typical of his compositions for solo instrument with orchestra. Of course, there aren't many by Ravel. Except for the three-movement G-Major Piano Concerto — the one using both hands — they are all based in some manner on the basic form of the Romany (aka Gypsy) rhapsody. The others include Tzigane for violin and orchestra and the notoriously bravura Concerto in D Major, using only the pianist's left hand. (Pianist Robert Casadesus once noted that, "With the other hand the pianist is praying, to hold on to reality for dear life.")


The Eos Ensemble

All these first three pieces received fine performances. The Roussel Trio got off to a mildly ragged start but soon caught the breeze into smooth sailing. Harpist Rado, a faculty member at the San Francisco Conservatory, was especially resonant and clear of sound. But whereas those were "fine" presentations, the mounting of the Ravel Quartet was sensational. Every little detail was perfectly in place and meticulously balanced. I've rarely heard this overprogrammed quartet so admirably played. Violinists Reiss and Elbert Tsai, violist Emily Onderdonk, and cellist Ruth Lane deserved every decibel of their ovation.

I cannot seem to attend a chamber music concert these days without the Ravel Quartet on the program. I have the impression that were I to give a good slap to some sleeping string player, shouting "Ravel Quartet!" as I did so, their hands would automatically start fingering and bowing the piece even with no instrument in sight. That also means that frequency of encounter requires a high standard if the quartet is to make any impression at all. Sunday's performance did. I've been haunted by the slow movement ever since.

(Heuwell Tircuit is a composer, performer, and writer who was chief writer for Gramophone Japan and for 21 years a music reviewer for the San Francisco Chronicle. He wrote previously for Chicago's American and the Asahi Evening News.)

©2006 Heuwell Tircuit, all rights reserved