sfcv logo

RECITAL REVIEW

Aural Delectations

November 8, 2003

Nuccia Focile

E-mail this page

By Kip Cranna

The Italian soprano Nuccia Focile, who has established a stellar international career on the world's major operatic stages in roles ranging from Mozart to Puccini, came close to slipping under the San Francisco radar last Saturday in a low-profile appearance at UCSF's Laurel Heights Auditorium. While largely unheralded, the event was as bracing as a breath of fresh air, with just a whiff of sweet perfume.

Her fragrantly lightweight program — featuring large doses of what used to be known as “salon music” — can be pardoned for its overt audience appeal by its purpose: a benefit for cancer research at UCSF. Focile was presented by the New Century Chamber Orchestra, who provided accompaniment for several selections with nine string players led by Music Director and Concertmaster Krista Bennion Feeney. For the rest of the program the accomplished British pianist Ingrid Surgenor gave the singer firm and expert support.

Focile is an elegant presence and a versatile artist whose vocal production features a fluid legato, impressive technique, and a warm, rich tone that is solid and consistent throughout the range, with a youthful, even girlish quality at times despite its chiaroscuro shadings.

Dapprima, i dolci

She began with and old Italian standby, Gluck's “O del mio dolce ardor,” with the piano accompaniment joined by the strings. Her dark vocal tone allowed for little of the diction to come through, but there were rich colors in the sound. Next came a group of three Italian semi-classics that are close cousins of the Neapolitan canzona. (Focile used the score for these, as well as for various other light and popular offerings, suggesting they aren't necessarily staples of her repertoire.) Francesco Tosti's “L'ultima canzone” was meant for a man to sing to a sweetheart who is betrothed to someone else. Still, it was rendered artfully, with admirable flexibility and delicately spun shadings, despite a rather studious approach for this heart-on-the-sleeve fare. Respighi's “Nebbie” (Clouds) was sung with Verismo potency and energetic thrust, and Stanislas Gastaldon's “Musica proibita” was full-throated and appealing

Not surprisingly, some of Focile's most subtle work came in two French songs by Gabriel Fauré. “L'automne” was heartfelt and moving, and “Après un R've” had a brooding loveliness. Ravel's sultry gypsy-style vocalise entitled “Pièce en forme de Habanera” explored the singer's ample lower voice, and showcased her agility in neatly nuanced turns and trills. Ravel's simulated Spain was followed by three genuine Spanish songs by Fernando Obradors. In the spirited “El Vito,” pianist Surgenor showed firm command in the insistently hammering accompaniment. “Coplas de Curro Dulce” gave Focile a chance to dash off plenty of hot-blooded flamenco-style vocal flourishes, with a show-biz touch that would have done well in the encore section.

Focile included only two operatic numbers, both by Puccini. Liu's aria “Tu che di gel sei cinta” from Turandot was first-rate, exemplary in its unmannered yet stirring emotion. One can readily imagine how effective she must be in the role. By contrast Musetta's waltz-song from La Bohème seemed a bit labored and forced, suggesting that her onstage Musetta would be a fearsome spitfire indeed.

Domestic fare

A set of four Gershwin songs, nicely underpinned by Michael Burr on double bass, mostly came across as stiff and overly precious, but in “My Man's Gone Now” from Porgy and Bess Focile unleashed a vocal force thoroughly committed and convincing in its power.

Next came operetta, in the form of the “Vilja” song from The Merry Widow (sung in the original German though curiously titled in Italian in the printed program). Focile seemed nicely at home in this schmaltzy Viennese vein, with stylish phrasing and only a smidgen of tension on the top notes.

In a creative programming move, she included three songs by the rarely heard Welsh-born composer Ivor Novello (1893-15951), famous for his World War I standard “Keep the Home Fires Burning” and creator of various West End musicals in the 1930's. With just the right dash of sentiment, she made these middle-brow, sugary parlor songs seem almost inspired, with top honors going to “Waltz of My Heart.”

Departing confections

Emboldened even further in her flirtation with slightly déclassé repertoire, Focile gamely tackled Rossini's glitzy showpiece “La Danza,” joined by the NCCO's strings to provide a corny if flashy finish. For a redeeming encore she turned again to Porgy and Bess for a creamy and delicious rendition of “Summertime.”

The only purely instrumental selection offered by the chamber orchestra was a rather rough and bass-heavy treatment of Mozart's Eine Kleine Nachtmusik, whose classic refinement seemed a bit out place in what was otherwise an evening laden with bonbons.

(Clifford (Kip) Cranna is Musical Administrator of the San Francisco Opera, lectures frequently on music appreciation, and teaches courses on opera at the San Francisco Conservatory's Adult Extension Division.)

©2003 Kip Cranna, all rights reserved