|
RECITAL REVIEW
March 18, 2006
|
Broad Selection By Scott Cmiel
Tilman Hoppstock brought beautiful tone, a wide dynamic range, and an
impeccable technique to a fascinating and thought-provoking program for solo guitar at the California Palace of the Legion of Honor, featuring baroque improvisation and contemporary aleatoric music, meticulous adherence to some traditional scores, and bold recomposition of others.
Hoppstock opened Robert De Visée's Suite in D Minor with an extended
improvisation in baroque style. The use of motives from the suite to
follow, as well as rhythmic freedom and idiomatic virtuosity of
improvisation, made for a captivating beginning to the evening that
followed the practice of many baroque musicians. De Visée was guitarist
and composer to Louis XIV of France. His Suite in D Minor consists of
prelude, allemande, courante, sarabande, and gigue, plus a series of
optional additional dances. Hoppstock chose to add a bourée between the
sarabande and gigue, thus reproducing the order chosen by Bach for
several of his suites. The ornamentation was elegant and the dance
rhythms were clear and expressive.
Next followed a stylistically diverse set of three tombeaux, originally a
baroque form written as a lament on the occasion of the death of a
prominent figure. Hoppstock's set consisted of Lamento by Johann
Froberger, Homenaje, "Le tombeau de Claude Debussy" by Manuel de Falla and Hika: In Memoriam Toru Takemitsu by Leo Brouwer.
Froberger's Lamento is a particularly expressive 17th century piece which features unusually low tessitura, slow-moving minor harmonies, poignant modulations, and dramatic pauses. Written in memory of lutenist Charles Fleury it also inverts a traditional convention. Seventeenth century tombeaux frequently featured a slowly rising scale meant to symbolize the soul of the departed ascending to heaven. It seems that Fleury died when he fell down the stairs to his wine cellar. Froberger's piece concludes with a rapid scale, dramatically introduced, and ends with a jolt. Hoppstock played the music with great pathos and the final passage with admirable vigor. Falla's Homenaje, with its plethora of articulation, dynamic, and tempo markings, is well known to guitarists. Hoppstock performed it with an austere precision perfectly calibrated to bring out the work's barely contained passion. Leo Brouwer marked Toru Takemitsu's death with his composition Hika, a moody elegy based on a Bulgarian theme that Takemitsu loved. The use of retuned second and fifth strings allowed Brouwer to create an exotic atmosphere well captured by the soloist. Hoppstock's decision to group these disparate meditations on death was stimulating. Ferdinando Carulli was an Italian guitarist and composer active in Paris in the early 19th century, where he was the center of a guitar craze which brought him fame and fortune. A prolific composer, he published 366 opus numbers, which featured rapid arpeggios; scales; passages in thirds, sixths, and octaves; slurs; glissandos; and harmonics. I had never heard a composition by Carulli that I enjoyed, so I awaited this part of the program with some trepidation. In an engaging introduction, Hoppstock spoke of the need to search through Carulli's many scores to find the rare gem and admitted having recomposed the music he was going to play in the style of Mozart. I assume it was for one of these reasons I found the selections enjoyable.
Andrés Segovia, the great 20th century Spanish guitarist, also indulged in the art of significantly altering the work of composers. When Manuel Ponce presented him with a set of 24 preludes in all major and minor keys, Segovia culled the selections he found ineffective and altered the keys of others to place them in more resonant parts of the guitar. While the integrity of the original composition was violated, the selection of preludes that Hoppstock performed left me less concerned with Segovia's audacity than impressed by his good judgment and musicality. Brouwer's music was featured twice at the end of the program. First his Tarantos, a response to the flamenco form, was paired with a more traditional flamenco Taranta by Paco de Lucia. Finally his La Espiral Eterna no less than an exploration of the structure of the universe concluded the program. The score draws its inspiration from a spiral galaxy whose structure can be seen in the smallest of life forms on earth. In four imaginative sections Brouwer explores the function of spiral forms in gaseous nebulae, the birth of stars, molecular structure, and the beginning of life. The first section begins with a three-note cluster played tremolando, which expands and contracts in a continuous wave of sound until it finally resolves into a single note. The second section explores percussive effects and moves toward micro tonality. The third section uses aleatoric effects with both hands playing on the fretboard. The fourth section incorporates improvisation, Cuban dance rhythms, and a return to the note clusters of the beginning. Hoppstock had complete control over every aspect of this demanding masterpiece. It was a magnificent end to a compelling recital.
(Scott Cmiel is a guitarist on the faculties of the San Francisco Conservatory and UC Berkeley.)
|
Tilman Hoppstock