|
RECITAL REVIEW
January 23, 2005
|
By Heuwell Tircuit
Something new and something old made up the format of violinist Jennifer Koh's Sunday afternoon recital in the new Kanbar Hall of the Jewish Community Center. Among other things, the program was presented as part of 25th Anniversary of San Francisco Performances, but such a program was new in the Kanbar series.
Variety to the fore, Koh and her pianist partner Reiko Uchida presented a fascinating display of musicianship and sheer class while avoiding standardized programming clichés. The duo opened with Schumann's Violin Sonata No. 1 in A Minor, Op. 105, John Adams' new Road Movies and Ravel's spiffy Violin Sonata in G Major. Following intermission, Koh played another new piece, Esa-Pekka Salonen's Lachen Verlernt (Laughing Unlearnt) for unaccompanied violin, then more Schumann, the Fantasiestücke, Op. 73, and Franz Waxman's Carmen Fantasy. Despite much audience clamor, there was no encore. But it had been a demanding two hours topped by the taxing Waxman.
A winner of the 1994-95 Tchaikovsky Competition, Chicago-born Koh has become one of the bright spots on the American music scene. Not only does she play so well and with such sensibility to individual style, but she also obviously possesses a superior sense of mission as well as the intellectual equipment to match her dexterity. Only her last two offerings, Schumann's three Fantasy pieces and the generally neglected Bizet-Waxman operatic fantasy, presented reasonably familiar music.
Koh seems equally at home in chamber music, playing solo or with orchestras. Her broad repertory interests know no bounds, from Baroque through the newest modern works. Yet there's no evidence of hard-sell showbiz in her stage manner: no swooning gesture of the head or throwing the bow up in the air, etc. Her playing was all the more convincing in that it never sought to distract from the music itself. As a result we could simply listen — listen and marvel. Koh clearly knows style to a fine degree. The smoldering, mildly morbid Schumann Sonata gave way to a more Lieder-like account of Schumann's three Fantasy pieces. Yet she could match Ravel's three unmatched movements, each with its own quality: a mildly pastoral first, the “Blues” second and the scampering perpetual-motion third movement. She, further, caught the constant references to American pops style. The Sonata stands as Ravel's second most Americanized piece. Only the two-handed Piano Concerto in G is more overtly jazzy. Although very well played, neither of the new works was very impressive. Adams' three-movement Road Movies has nothing to do with either roads or movies. In place of tempo marking, Adams' uses “relaxed groves,” “meditation” and “40% swing.” The first movement came off sounding like a fantasy on Stravinsky's Duo Concertant; the effective meditation was the most interesting; while the finale sounded merely like a lot of meaningless scampering. The saving grace of Adams' style is that he's less tenacious about repeating motives than the average minimalist. He doesn't go on and on without variation, ad nauseam.
Salonen is, of course, the outstanding conductor of the Los Angeles Philharmonic. My few encounters have found his compositions all on the avant-garde side, a tad à la Boulez. So it came as a major surprise that his Laughing Unlearnt (the title is derived from Schoenberg's Pierrot Lunaire) is relatively conservative melodically and rather staid rhythmically. Something akin to a set of variations, the piece seemed like an act of homage to violin cadenzas. Flashy, yes, but the materials fell as quite bland on my ears. What a kick, to experience the Waxman piece again after something like 30 years. Sarasate's Carmen Fantasy is a rather commonplace event, while the more brilliant and inclusive Waxman is perhaps frightening to the average fiddler. It was written in 1947 for Waxman's neighbor Jascha Heifetz, as a maximum display of technique. This, Waxman accomplished. The Koh performance was a jaw dropper, flawless in every detail. The woman knows no fear. She tore into that thing with all the appearance of someone merely playing “Come to Jesus” in whole notes. Koh has the blessing of excellent partnership from Reiko Uchida. I gather that they appear together fairly regularly. Their match of dynamic balances and turn-on-a-dime rubato ensemble, without even minor flaws as fine duos can do was beautiful to hear.
Seating a few less than 500, the new hall is handsome and comfortable, save for lighting so dim that people were having a difficult time finding their way down the black stairway from the bleacher-type seating. It's a minor danger, but a danger nevertheless. The sonics are bright and clean a bit too clean. With carpeting and something like cloth-textured wall covering, the acoustics tend to be a bit clinical. There's very little reverberation to warm the general effect. This will no doubt be an advantage for speakers, but it's an impediment to full musical enjoyment.
(Heuwell Tircuit, composer, performer and writer, was chief writer for Gramophone Japan and for 21 years a music reviewer for the SF Chronicle, previously for the Chicago American and Asahi Evening News.)
|
Jennifer Koh
Reiko Uchida