sfcv logo
IN Music News THIS WEEK:

Young Singers Get the Word on Real Life

February 19, 2002

By Janos Gereben

Young Singers Get the Word on Real Life

Between a San Francisco Performances recital in Herbst Theater Saturday night and a master class for amateurs Sunday afternoon, soprano Barbara Bonney gave a morning presentation on the business of music. She told young singers about the realities of singing as a career — "figure on 30% of your income cleared after international/US taxes (56% in Germany alone) and make sure your expenses and living costs are covered by what remains, good luck to you!" — and she peppered her eminently practical advice with fun bits of information:

  • Be true to your voice; if you're a lyric soprano, don't let 'em try "to make your voice big because that's what sells." Even such respected conductors as Nicholas Harnoncourt and Simon Rattle can fall for this, Bonney said, rolling her eyes vigorously, the former suggesting Fidelio to her, the latter Donna Anna. Those revolving eyes went into earth orbit when Bonney contemplated Charlotte Church singing Vissi d'arte.
  • Keep track of what you wear for recitals in which city. She does that (and makes sure she doesn't repeat repertory either) with an Excel spreadsheet. The cost of her superb gown Friday night in Herbst Theater: $109, including tax, but she wouldn't reveal the source lest the place is over-run by thrifty singers.
  • Managers work for you, not the other way around, Bonney said sternly. "You are the CEO of yourself."
  • Don't overdo "protecting the voice." An example: "dear Kathy Battle writing notes" backstage. The other end of the scale: Neil Schicoff, "who sings through his entire role three times immediately before the performance, oh dear!" Incidentally, Bonney's own five-hour speaking binge on top of the two-hour recital took place just 72 hours before her concert in Carnegie Hall. That's practicing what you teach, with gusto.
  • Being a waiter/waitress is an excellent way of assuring survival for the young singer — Bonney spent seven years doing it — because it helps developing skills needed on the stage: timing, discipline and endearing yourself to the paying/tipping/applauding public.
  • Her singing idols: Elisabeth Schumann, Ella Fitzgerald and Yo-Yo Ma.
  • Advantages of fame: when she started her career in Dortmund, the New Jersey-born soprano had 120 performances in her first year, plus rehearsals, of course, leaving her four days off. A recitalist and opera singer in demand around the world now, Bonney graduated to 35 days at home last year. "You will not see much of your family or friends," she said. "It gets very lonely out there."
  • Recording are good for the ego, as "calling cards," but there is no money in them for the artist. With 85 CDs under her belt, Bonney is still waiting for her first royalty check. But it's all rather irrelevant, she said, because new classical recordings are disappearing anyway.
  • "Diva days" are almost over, except for "the Strauss-Puccini crowd." Mozart singers like herself behave much better, she joked. Or did she?
  • With all the difficulties, hardship, challenges, dangers in path of the young singer, what is one to do? Bonney suggested sincerity, integrity and "enjoying the hell out of music."

& & &

The Last of the Class of 1912

Günter Wand, who turned 90 in January, died Thursday in Switzerland. The last of great conductors born in 1912 — Sergiu Celibidache, Erich Leinsdorf, Ernst Ludwig Leitner, Sir Georg Solti among others — Wand did not have an international, jet-setter career, but his work in Cologne and Bern over the years was much appreciated by music lovers. Late in life, his recordings began to make a name for him everywhere, especially his superb Bruckner performances.

& & &

Terfel Slows Down

Bryn Terfel, the Sydney Morning Herald reports, cancelled his planned appearance with Opera Australia next year "in the title role" of Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg. In fact, it's the role of Hans Sachs that's at issue, but apparently the report of cancellation is correct. Only 36, Terfel has now cancelled all engagements outside Europe, in order to spend more time with his family. "Singing isn't everything," he said. "Life and family are."

The Sydney company's general manager, Adrian Collette, did not celebrate Terfel's change of heart. "This production was central to our planning for 2003," he said, "and no one is going to bring to it the box-office clout of Bryn Terfel." That clout is badly needed because the Wagner opera's production cost is A$2 million there, which is $1 million "in real money."

& & &

East Coast Inferiority Complex

"The stodgy New York Philharmonic is all but stagnating under the lame-duck leadership of its Old World maestro, Kurt Masur, and the immediate future under Lorin Maazel looms ominous," writes Martin Bernheimer in the February 18 Financial Times by way of setting the scene for the report on the San Francisco Symphony's visit to Carnegie Hall last week. Applauding Michael Tilson Thomas's direction and Thomas Hampson's performance in Mahler's Das Lied von der Erde (but not happy with tenor Michael Schade), Bernheimer concludes that Esa-Pekka Salonen in Los Angeles and MTT in San Francisco are gaining on the band in New York - "... a couple of symphonic mavericks are making interesting music, their way, in the not-so-wild west."

& & &

And an Oops in Philadelphia

Thomas Zehetmair was advertised as the Philadelphia Orchestra's soloist last week in Mozart's Violin Concerto No. 4, but — according to Peter Dobrin's report in the Philadelphia Inquirer — he went for a stroll on Friday before the evening concert scheduled in the new Kimmel Center Verizon Hall. But this was no evening concert: the matinee started at 2 p.m., without the soloist to be found anywhere.

Neeme Järvi went on to conduct the concert's other scheduled work, Gliere's Symphony No. 3, and the audience of 2,500 ended up Mozart-less. Zehetmair said he was miserable about the mixup, he apologized, but offered an excuse which doesn't seem entirely acceptable: "I have been performing for 24 years or something, and it's really the first time this has happened." How many concerts can a soloist miss before the problem becomes obvious?

=========

(Janos Gereben, a regular contributor to www.sfcv.org, is arts editor of the Post Newspaper Group. His e-mail address is janos451@earthlink.net.)

©2002 Janos Gereben, all rights reserved