|
SYMPHONY REVIEW
February 22, 2004
|
By Scott MacClelland
Now halfway through its 46th season, the Santa Cruz County Symphony consistently makes its community proud. Its subscription concerts are performed at Santa Cruz Civic Auditorium, a barn-like multiuse facility that also hosts the Cabrillo Festival, and at the Henry J. Mello Performing Arts Center located at Watsonville High School. John Larry Granger is now in his 13th season as music director and has raised the technical standards of the orchestra to an all-time high.
In many ways, Granger is the ideal conductor of a regional orchestra, at once an exacting disciplinarian, orchestra builder and artistic visionary. Moreover, his greater artistic success has come from a much smaller budget than that of the nearby Monterey. A small number of generous angels regularly provide additional sponsorship.
Unlike many symphony conductors on the regional level, Granger continues to grow artistically and arrives at the office with his homework done. But that doesn't always guarantee a successful result. Santa Cruz Civic is an acoustically treacherous room, ever ready to distort balances and sonorities. The Mello Center, built after the Loma Prieta earthquake irreparably damaged its predecessor high school auditorium, is a much better venue, dry but bright and clear, and, after trial and error, now delivering a well-balanced and full-bodied sonic image. This comment follows last Sunday's performance at the Mello of works by Mozart, Ibert, Mollicone and Beethoven.
In spite of initial hints, Henry Mollicone's twelve-minute Dansa Trimbula, composed in 1995 for the San Jose Chamber Orchestra, is no Argentine tango. This concert work for saxophone (alternating the alto and soprano instruments), accordion, piano, percussion and strings lets you know there's a debt to be paid. It may be owed to the devil, as ancient legends often recount through music. Or to a Mafioso don as implied by Sicilian turns of phrase and menacing chromatic intimations. Even the tango rhythm gets surreal, not unlike Ravel's La valse. But as wild and original as Astor Piazzolla Mollicone's putative inspiration for this piece gets, Trimbula blazes a new and even more disturbing trail. While it would be easy to excuse the work's idiosyncrasies, attributing them to Mollicone's local history (he lives in Saratoga and has had works premiered throughout the San Francisco Bay Area, not least by the Santa Cruz Symphony itself) and its dedicatee, Santa Cruz's resident saxophone guru William Trimble, the piece itself deserves universal attention. We live in a brave world of new music, and Mollicone has now emerged especially in this piece as a legitimate if unexpected pioneer. During his career, Piazzolla (1921-1992) took a closer look at the Argentine national dance and turned up a treasury of unexpected gems. In Trimbula, Mollicone diffracted it through his own cultural lenses with ironic and mysterious results, not least exploiting Trimble's virtuoso vocabulary. In this reading, master accordionist Anthony Quartuccio whom Mollicone also had in mind when writing the piece spoke Argentine tango with a Neapolitan accent (adding unsightly and amusing bellow-shake tremolos during the saxophone/accordion cadenza.) Pianist Stephen Tosh took delight in the many musical quotes and allusions of pre-existing works, and Larry Granger had his hands full with tricky rhythms and mood changes.
The Sunday afternoon audience gained the advantage of the Symphony's best venue and the added polish afforded by a performance of this program the night before. The overall result represented the orchestra's best through the overture to Mozart's Abduction from the Seraglio, Ibert's Concertino da Camera for saxophone, and Beethoven's Symphony No. 7 in A. Granger, who prefers to conduct from memory, plainly had an interpretation in mind for the Beethoven. In this case, the first movement was shaped according to its long phrases rather than strong contrasts as some 18th century “specialists” have gained fame doing. The second movement, allegretto, was well paced and skillfully detailed in its textures and dialogues between the strings and winds. The attentive listener was paid off handsomely. The energy level picked up startlingly in the quick-stepping presto and caught fire fully in the vividly bursting finale. This was a performance conceived across the entire span of the piece and built to excellent effect. The Mozart wanted only more presence from its metal percussion (triangle and cymbals.) Though the French Ibert echoes American jazz, that inflection is painted more in pastels than other hybrid examples (like Milhaud's Creation du monde and Ravel's Piano Concerto in G.) As such, Trimble played a seductive and sensuous performance, sweet in the slow movement and otherwise engaging, but barely suggesting the level of virtuosity demanded by the ensuing Mollicone.
(Scott MacClelland, since 1978, has written music criticism and journalism for all the major newspapers on the Monterey Peninsula, and for the Metro papers in Santa Cruz and San Jose. During the same period, he has taught music history for Monterey Peninsula College.)
|