Robert P. Commanday

Robert P. Commanday, founding editor of San Francisco Classical Voice, was the music critic of The San Francisco Chronicle from 1965 to 1993, and before that a conductor and lecturer at UC Berkeley.

Articles by this Author

S.F. Symphony History: Eyewitness Stories Retold - Article
October 25, 2011

Book CoverThe biography of a symphony orchestra is inevitably more than that. It’s a segment of the history of its community, of succeeding generations sacrificing and dedicating great commitment to ensure and to grow the instrument. The story of San Francisco’s first major orchestra is assumed to begin in 1912 with the founding of the San Francisco Symphony and its premiere concert under Henry Hadley.

Seattle’s Intense Porgy and Bess - Review
August 22, 2011

Gordon Hawkins (Porgy) and Lisa Daltirus (Bess)<br/>Photos by Elise BakketunPorgy and Bess is surely an opera, beyond a musical, when all the performing stars are aligned.

S.F. Opera’s Götterdämmerung a Complete Work of Art - Review
June 6, 2011

Related Article

Out of the Ashes, a Goddess Emerges

Another perspective on Götterdämmerung from Jason Victor Serinus

Spiriting Vivaldi - Review
May 31, 2011

Vivaldi wrote so few sacred works (72), relative to his prodigious instrumental output and 46 operas, that it’s curious that it wasn’t until last Saturday that a significant church composition of his was performed here for the first time. Chora Nova performed Vivaldi’s Dixit Dominus, RV 807, accompanied by a period instrument orchestra, in Berkeley’s First Congregational Church, and it is a work of high quality.

Siegfried’s Split Personality - Review
May 30, 2011

Related Article

Siegfried: A Glorious Prelude to Collapse

Jason Serinus' review of Siegfried

Cal Bach Does Justice to Brahms’ Choral Legacy - Review
May 3, 2011

While Brahms composed the finest choral music in the 19th century, and a lot of it, try to find a performance of much of it today, aside from Ein Deutsches Requiem. Finally, one excellent chamber choir came up with a program worthy of “Johannes Brahms and the German Legacy.” The California Bach Society, performing it for the third time Sunday at St. Mark's Church in Berkeley, did proper justice to the subject, in a beautifully sung and fitting conclusion to its 40th season.

To Honor Andrew Imbrie - Preview
March 22, 2011

His 90th birthday anniversary triggers the celebrations of the late Andrew Imbrie and his music. On Friday, March 25, Composers Inc. kicks off the series with a promising program featuring new works written to honor his memory by former students David del Tredici, Richard Festinger, and Hi Kyung Kim, and another new piece in Imbrie’s honor by his distinguished colleague and friend Yehudi Wyner.

Alive, Awake, and Singing - Review
January 11, 2011

It’s still here! The male chorus — particularly the college glee club, that is. A prominent and proficient exemplar of a breed and a great tradition thought to have been diminishing, the Cornell University Glee Club from Ithaca, N.Y., made a fine concert showing Saturday at the San Francisco Conservatory of Music.

In Memoriam: Jane Galante 1924-2010 - Article
December 7, 2010

Jane Hohfeld Galante, a leading chamber musician and prominent San Franciscan, died at her home in San Francisco Wednesday morning. She was 86. She had been a leader in San Francisco’s chamber music scene for more than 60 years as a pianist, scholar, board member, and vigorous advocate of music and education.

Seattle Opera's Winning Tristan und Isolde - Review
August 14, 2010

Were there the shadow of a doubt of the continuing and historic power of Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde to capture and move its audiences, this summer’s Seattle Opera production dispelled it, two major shortcomings notwithstanding. The leading strength in Thursday’s fourth of seven performances was, appropriately, the orchestra. It was led with a sure sense of the music’s intensities, expressiveness, and dynamic properties by Asher Fisch, principal guest conductor.

In Memoriam: Alan Rich
1924-2010
- Article
April 27, 2010

Alan Rich, America’s most outspoken classical music critic, died in his sleep Friday in his home in West Los Angeles at the age of 85. For his entire career, he was as full-out in his enthusiasms and advocacies as he was unsparing and sharp in his assessments, always making a deep impression. He was, in short, a leading commentator on the classical music scene, one who would not just engage but stir his reader.

Dustup in Sonoma County - Article
February 23, 2010

The dust had not even settled after the Green Music Center’s successful acoustical debut on Feb. 12, when a storm blew up in Sonoma County turning that dust into a gray cloud over the entire project. The storm last Thursday, Feb. 18, was the raid by the FBI and other investigators on Sonoma State University’s administration and finance department and the seizure of computers and boxes of records.

Music Center at Sonoma State Still A-Greening - Review
February 16, 2010

While California and its constituent parts sit in a blue mood, Sonoma County on Friday night was celebrating the future and its hopes. At least, 350 of its movers and shakers were doing that, the donors who had raised much of the $96 million toward building the Green Music Center on the Rohnert Park campus of Sonoma State University. In their presence that night, the Santa Rosa Symphony gave the first real test to the auditorium that bids to be the prime symphony hall in Northern California.

In Memoriam: Mariedi Anders
1915-2009
- Article
December 29, 2009

Mariedi Anders, a leading American concert manager and the first in San Francisco, died Dec. 26 in the California Pacific Hospital after a short illness. She was 94. She was a major agent on the West Coast, managing her Mariedi Anders Artists Management, Inc., for 50 years, right up to her death. She was noted throughout the industry for her devotion to her artists, her energy, and her determination in the introduction of new artists.

Dohnányi to the Fore - Review
October 27, 2009

The San Francisco Symphony’s Chamber Music Series, offered most Sunday afternoons, is a dependable bet. There, members of the Symphony emerge as individuals from orchestral submersion and can be heard doing what they most like to do, as best they can. The players, not the Symphony, program it, so there is little or no Russian music, no Mahler, but rather music of fresh interest — as was the case last Sunday in Davies Symphony Hall.

Seattle Ring Achieves
a Triumphant Finale
- Review
August 17, 2009

The Seattle Opera’s Siegfried performed heroically on Wednesday, fighting the lingering effects of an illness more challenging than Fafner the dragon. Stig Andersen’s strategy worked.

A New Look in a Traditional Ring - Review
August 11, 2009

There’s a lot of life left in the old Ring myth, made abundantly apparent Sunday and Monday in the opening of Seattle Opera’s current rerunning of Wagner’s tetralogy. With Stephen Wadsworth’s imaginative direction, the first two operas, Das Rheingold and Die Walküre, were wholly engaging, his fresh interpretation showing how little need there is to transport the story into different times, cultures, or modern places, to try to make obvious strained metaphors of class or economic conflict or whatever. 

Hale and Farewell - Review
June 2, 2009

The musically merry month of May came to a close on Sunday, traditionally as ever, with concerts conjoined to graduations, two that could not have been more different. The first, in the afternoon at Stanford's Dinkelspiel Auditorium, found the Palo Alto Chamber Orchestra (aka PACO) both featuring and graduating 18 senior members, headed now for 15 different universities, the Eastman School of Music, and two fine colleges.

Stretching Summer Festival Season - Review
March 17, 2009

A summer-style music festival in the middle of March? There it was, full-blown in Boca Raton, Florida, the resort community's third annual Festival of the Arts Boca, March 5-15.

Shout to Heaven - Review
December 16, 2008

The Santa Rosa Symphony has more than earned its role as the future orchestra-in-residence at the Green Music Center, now edging toward completion at Sonoma State University (see the feature article). It has made remarkable progress during the past two decades, even under the handicap of an acoustically mediocre home.