Published Tuesdays


November 9, 1999



Reviews

OPERA REVIEW

Making Wozzeck Safe

San Francisco Opera
(11/5/99)

SYMPHONY REVIEW

Temirkanov Gets It On
With The Symphony


San Francisco Symphony
(11/6/99)

CHAMBER MUSIC REVIEW

Pressler Inspiring
Musical Dialog


San Francisco Conservatory
(11/4/99)

RECITAL REVIEW

Dame Kiri's Uncommonly
"Pretty" Singing


Kiri Te Kanawa
(11/7/99)

RECITAL REVIEW

A Singer Outside
Of His Music


Stephen Salters
(11/3/99)

CHAMBER MUSIC REVIEW

The Borodin--Still
At Their Peak


Borodin Quartet
(11/7/99)

EARLY MUSIC REVIEW

Philharmonia--Back
To The Baroque


Philharmonia Baroque
(11/6/99)

SYMPHONY REVIEW

Marin Does It
With Concertos


Marin Symphony
(11/7/99)

CHORAL REVIEW

SF State Singers Shine
In Joint Program


SF State Chamber Singers/Sacred and Profane
(11/6/99)

Robert P. Commanday, Editor

In Search of Lost Time

I was multitasking last week, as most folks do these days, when a voice from the distance (fourth level of consciousness) drew my attention to a radio interview with the author of Faster: The Acceleration of Just About Everything . Click and Bingo! James Gleick was hitting it right on our button, about how we are not only doing everything faster, more "efficiently," "saving" time, but that the service/entertainment industry is doing it for itself and, presumably "for" us. To take just one sector, they're shaving "waste"seconds and microseconds from television shows and commercials and trimming down film frames per sequence, double and triple cutting, jumping, overlapping and interleaving images and scenes till Hell won't have it. Seen a movie preview lately?

Scary as are all the implications of what Gleick tells and reminds us about the drive to accelerate every aspect of our waking and sleeping lives, that's not the half of it. His observations made a connection with other speculations about how we've been changing and how that has changed our relationship to music, our way of hearing and processing it. These changes are revolutionary, and so fundamental that they tell us we have already crossed over into the Millennium. The future is now.

Clearly what music we listen to, how we listen and how we create it is influenced by all the music and sound that we take in around us. Other forces are affecting all that however. The technological revolution is working a profound change, not just in our music, but in us. In his brilliant book, The Gutenberg Elegies: The Fate of Reading in an Electronic Age (Fawcett Columbine, 1994), Sven Birkerts describes our living now through a period of "overlap in communication modes, and the ways of living they are associated with." He compares this to the transitional epoch in ancient Greek society during Socrates' time, when the "dominant oral culture was overtaken by the writing technology," and then to the later epochal transition in the late 15th century after Gutenberg invented movable type and now to the overlap of the printed word by the electronic media.

Listening Differently

We now read differently, thanks to the hours spent in front of the screen, skimming, skipping, only infrequently scrolling back to reexamine a particularly interesting or elusive passage. If we are reading differently, our minds are beginning to work differently. To the extent of that, I suspect we are beginning to listen to music differently as well.

If we agree with the late Joseph Brodsky's observation that "Aesthetic choice is a highly individual matter, and aesthetic experience is always a private one," we must recognize that the electronic medium does not readily support that condition. Birkerts maintains that "while circuit and screen are ideal conduits for certain kinds of data–they are entirely inhospitable to the more subjective materials that have always been the stuff of art. That is to say, they are antithetical to inwardness... The main reason has to do with time... The time of the self is deep time, duration time... To the extent that we immerse ourselves in a book, listen to music, sink into the visual realm of a painting, to that degree we surrender our awareness of the present as a coordinate on a grid... All circuit-driven communications, by contrast, are predicated upon instantaneousness."

And that brings us to James Gleick's Faster. As he describes the condition of a society in a rush, of the "compression of time that characterizes the life of the century now closing," you recognize this compulsion in the acceleration devices at every hand--the door-close button, the speed-dial button, the remote control and countless other mechanisms. Time is now micro-measured in nano-seconds. We have the modern concept of "real time" which means right now or sooner. And now, in Internet time, thought and consideration give way to immediacy of communication, the imperative instantaneousness.

Gleick's book links up all the familiar patterns of compacted functioning. Obvious ones are cell-phoning and multi-tasking which may gratify with the "saturation of parallel pathways of the brain" but also condition behavioral patterns not exactly conducive to contemplation and considered decision making.

365 Ways To Save Time

The various media exploit the acceleration. Television news is compressed by commentators to create "instant reflectivity" and of course, sound bites. Studio editing equipment "measures raw bits of tape in hundredths of a second," enabling movie and video films to be jammed with faster images of more movement in less time and advertising spots to concentrate more information in less and less time. In chapters like "The Paradox of Efficiency," "365 Ways To Save Time" and "Eat and Run," we see the reflection of a society and culture racing to the horizon.

The musical public has to be affected. The art that has always assumed that listeners would devote time to 40- or 50-minute compositions and to full evening performances now faces an impatient public. Record companies provide the "compilation-anthology-sampler" category of CDs, assuming that "no single track will demand more than a few minutes' [time] investment." The surviving classical music stations program with an eye on "saving the minute." There are countless examples of performing institutions caving in or catering to this hurrying, restlessness of the public.

Music is different, and to rush or compress or abridge it is to negate its whole function. In pronouncing the truism that "music is the art form most clearly about time," Gleick points to the central issue but also, I believe, to the saving grace. Music is our best hope to help us hold on to our lives and control the pace and rhythm of it. It can yet hold us to an understanding and appreciation of time. Immersion in the time play which is part of every great work's expressive scheme can be a restorative of temporal perspective. The day's rushing, the seconds or minutes "saved," suddenly lose significance when we are submerged in a great symphony. Just that separation or stepping aside may be an important motivation to attend concerts–a sanctuary where time may be held still, in suspense.

It is true that some of the new music heard in that sanctuary compresses and layers information to extreme limits, overwhelming the senses and intellectual capacity, like speech that is too fast and too concentrated. And at the other end of the spectrum, perhaps in the same concert, some new music keeps the amount of musical information down to the point where minimal attention and intellectual processing will lead to gratification for many and tedium for others. But the experiencing of these extremes also fulfills our need to regain our temporal composure, to reset our tempo for living.

It may well be that music in its example and inspiration may restore meditation, contemplation, the time we have lost and continue to lose in the mad race to save time. Music, perhaps uniquely, has that power.

-----Robert Commanday

_________________________

Mary F. Commanday, Assoc. Editor

______________________________________

We welcome commentary, suggestions and reactions to the articles. Simply click on "Contact Us" and send your reponse by e-mail.

Also--all previous reviews and articles are available.
For last week's issue and articles, click on "Last Week." To retrieve earlier pieces, click on "archives" at the bottom of the page, enter the category and/or specifics of the search query, then click "Submit." If an article fails to appear, please notify us by e-mail ("Contact Us").