Published Tuesdays


April 9, 2002



Reviews

CONTEMPORARY MUSIC

Restless Bird

By George Thomson
eighth blackbird
(4/5/02)

EARLY MUSIC

Love & Loss Chez Monteverdi

By Michelle Dulak
Magnificat
(4/7/02)

RECITAL

The Chameleon

By Sarah Cahill
Richard Goode
(4/2/02)

CHAMBER ORCHESTRA

Crisp & Dynamic

By Thomas Schultz
Australian Chamber Orchestra
Stephen Hough
(4/4/02)

RECITAL

The Beautiful and the Deep

By Stephanie Friedman
Elena Bocharova
Brad Alexander
(4/7/02)

RECITAL

A Recital With a Broken Wing

By Jerry Kuderna
Murray Perahia (4/7/02)

OPERA

Jovial Romp for Xerxes

By Kip Cranna
Pocket Opera, Xerxes (4/7/02)

CHAMBER MUSIC

Schubert to Dvorak with the FOG Trio

By Benjamin Frandzel
FOG Trio (3/25/02)

MUSIC NEWS

Pulitzer Follies

By Janos Gereben

***



Robert Commanday, Senior Editor

Nathan Schwartz, Musician Extraordinary

More than you know — the number of distinguished musicians in our midst who make invaluable contributions to our musical life yet are not celebrities, not household names. These treasures, some of them almost hidden, have one thing in common: their love, their passion for music is greater than their egos. The most representative of these, one who never sought attention for himself, who lived only to play and teach, was the pianist and chamber musician extraordinary, Nathan Schwartz. He died at the age of 73 in Kaiser Hospital, Oakland, Saturday evening after a six-year battle with leukemia, concluding a life that leaves us immeasurably richer — more than you know.

Schwartz did play solo works, of course, but was so dedicated to ensemble performance that he will be remembered first as a chamber musician. That was the designation I’m sure he preferred. In 1964, Nate, together with the cellist Bonnie Hampton, who became his wife seven years later, and the violinist David Abel, founded the Francesco Trio. Ten years later, the trio won the Naumburg Chamber Music Award, the highest chamber music honor in this country. During the 38 years since, the Francesco let up only to change violinists from time to time. Meanwhile, the Hampton-Schwartz Duo continued playing, regularly at the San Francisco Conservatory of Music where they have both been faculty members, he for the past 25 years.


Nathan Schwartz

If one word could capture Nathan Schwartz’ performances it would be “interior.” Whether the works were new, the ones that the Trio and Duo commissioned and introduced, or the masterworks of the repertory, he got inside the compositions, realizing them with an impeccable integrity, deep understanding and sympathy. No one was more sensitive an ensemble partner.

Either with his wife, or as keyboard partner for such artists as Zara Nelsova, André Novarra, Robert Mann, Felix Galimir, Eleanor Steber, Bethany Beardslee, Joel Krosnik, and Stuart Canin, Nathan Schwartz performed at music festivals in Santa Fe, Seattle, Banff, Ojai, Colorado, and of course here. He played at New York’s Alice Tully Hall, the Kennedy Center, the Library of Congress and on series in Boston, Los Angeles, London, Berlin, Amsterdam.

Nathan Schwartz was born in Montreal but, from the age of a few months, grew up in New York City through his four years at Columbia University, where he was elected to Phi Beta Kappa. By 1950, when I first knew him, Nate had come to the University of California Berkeley to earn an M.A. degree in music. He thereupon won the Alfred Hertz Fellowship with which he studied in France with the great Alfred Cortot and Paul Baumgartner. Subsequently, he served on faculties at Cal, with his wife at Grinnell College, Stanford University, the Banff Centre and the SF Conservatory.

His colleague at the Conservatory Mack McCray spoke of Nate’s piano teaching, his chamber music coaching, and his playing as a unified experience. “When we were holding master classes at school (performance seminars), he would hold his counsel for quite a while but then would open up, and I would shut up and listen. He astounded me, humbled me with such a musical approach to things. I would ask him what it was like to study with Cortot, and he would just laugh and say ‘You don’t want to hear about that.’ He treated it the way Mozart treated a secondary melody.”

In 1999, a year or so after he had been taking major medication for leukemia, I encountered Bonnie wheeling Nate, thin and enfeebled, into Kaiser for what she told me then was one of the twice or thrice weekly transfusions he needed to stay alive. He greeted me cheerily from the wheelchair and asked me how I was. Typical. The next I heard, was the miracle. He began a course of holistic treatments and special nutrients, and soon the red cell count began recovering. Very soon, the doctors discontinued the transfusions (not knowing what had reversed his condition). A year or so later, he was back on the Hellman Hall stage, walking and appearing as he had before the leukemia struck, and performing a duo recital with his wife. It was moving.

His faculty colleague Paul Hersh last Sunday recalled the last of the Thursday chamber music classes that Nathan Schwartz attended, a class in which some of 20 different groups will play. “He was having difficulty walking and seeing. The procedure is that (the four to seven faculty members present) are asked which piece they want to coach. Walter Piston’s Piano Trio came up and Nathan, who had never heard or played it, said in his humble way, ‘How can I coach this piece when I don’t know it?’ The students came out, Nathan staying there with his score, and they played the first movement. It was as if a needle of adrenalin had been inserted in him. When he gets going there’s no stopping him. He took off and was like a teen-ager. All of his infirmities and his age disappeared. He became one with the music he claimed he’d never heard before, and went at it with complete enthusiasm. When it was over, Bonnie had to take his arm and lead him out of there.”

Last Friday morning, Nate was at home practicing the Brahms G minor Piano Quartet he was scheduled to play in Minnesota, but by noon, he was coughing badly. Seriously ill in the afternoon, he spent the time listening to a favorite student’s recent recording of Beethoven’s Third Piano Concerto. In the hospital the next day, his systems failing, from behind the oxygen mask he asked his wife to bring him the Brahms score so that he could study it some more. As Hersh put it, “That was the way to go,” pursuing his passion for music.

________________________Robert Commanday

§ § §


There will be a graveside service for Nathan Schwartz tomorrow, April 10, at 2:00 p.m. at the Home of Eternity Cemetery (Mountain View Cemetery) 5000 Piedmont Ave., Oakland, and on Sunday, June 2, a Memorial Concert at the Crowden School, 1475 Rose St., Berkeley.

___________________________________

§ § § § § §

___________________________________

SFCV is a not-for-profit enterprise supported by foundation grants and individual contributions. If you enjoy what you find here and can help with a contribution, that support will help insure our continuance. Your contribution (tax-deductible) may be sent either to San Francisco Classical Voice, 6000 Wood Drive, Oakland, CA 94611, or to the San Francisco Foundation CIF, (San Francisco Classical Voice account), 225 Bush St. # 500, San Francisco, CA 94104.

(From September 1, 1998 to April 9, 2002, we have published, in addition to the Music News, feature pieces and weekly editorials, 1122 reviews of Bay Area performances by: 42 symphony orchestras (245 reviews), 57 chamber groups (127), 30 new music ensembles and programs (141), 29 opera companies (146), 21 choral groups (77), 18 music festivals (39), 26 early music ensembles (64), 17 chamber orchestras (50), 5 musical theater groups (12), world music (9) and recitals (206), youth music (6) )

_________________________

Robert Commanday, Senior Editor; Michelle Dulak, Editor; Richard Thomas, Associate Editor

______________________________________

We welcome commentary, suggestions and reactions to the articles. Simply click on editor@sfcv.org and send your response by e-mail.

Also — all previous reviews and articles are available.
For last week's issue and articles, click on "Last Week." To retrieve earlier pieces, click on "archives" at the bottom of the page, enter the category and/or specifics of the search query, then click "Submit." If an article fails to appear, please notify us by e-mail (editor@sfcv.org).