Nico Muhly’s New-Music Dream Team Plays a Full Hand at the Ace Hotel

Ben Kutner on May 13, 2019
Nico Muhly and friends at the Theatre at Ace Hotel: Muhly, Lisa Liu, Nadia Sirota, Caroline Shaw, Alex Sopp, Lisa Kaplan, and Wade Culbreath | Credit: Reed Hutchinson

Nico Muhly and an A-list crew of contemporary classical musicians played to an enthusiastic crowd Friday night at the Theatre at Ace Hotel in “Archives, Friends, Patterns.” The program featured works by Philip Glass as well as Muhly’s original work and collaborations with singer Thomas Bartlett (aka Doveman).

Nico Muhly | Credit: Reed Hutchinson

The ensemble included Pulitzer prize-winning composer and violinist Caroline Shaw, contemporary music violist Nadia Sirota, and new-music flutist Alex Sopp, among others. Actress Natalie Portman joined the musicians onstage as she performed a narration from Philip Glass’s CIVIL warS. The evening ran three hours and featured enough offerings to make any new-music lover giddy.

The concert was built around the concept of community. As Muhly told the audience, much of Glass’s early music was conceived for musician friends and tonight was Muhly’s own chance to perform music with his community. He mentioned that, in several cases, he had known members of the evening’s ensemble since he was 18. “We’re not 18 anymore, but that’s totally OK,” he added.

Lisa Liu, Nadia Sirota, Caroline Shaw, and Alex Sopp | Credit: Reed Hutchinson

The first half of the program featured a wide range of Glass’s work, rearranged by Muhly for the evening’s ensemble. Sopp and Shaw alternated on vocals and instruments throughout much of the set. Shaw gave a commanding performance when the ensemble performed a section of Another Look at Harmony. Her breath capacity was expansive and athletic.

A highlight was music from the ending of Glass’s 1984 film, Mishima: A Life in Four Chapters. Glass is at his most recognizable in this piece that felt fresh and vibrant on this program.

Another work of Glass’s, however, did not resonate as well. His suite from the film Étoile Polaire tended to feel long-winded at times. Glass can sound like a parody of himself and that was the case here. The near repetition of the same bars for several minutes fell flat.

Natalie Portman with Nico Muhly and Lisa Liu | Credit: Reed Hutchinson

In a surprise appearance, Portman was called up from the audience to narrate Glass’s CIVIL warS, from the composer’s collaboration with theater director Robert Wilson. Her narration, often manic on lines like, “How come I have bruises,” was particularly poignant against the ensemble’s strong string playing.

Muhly and Bartlett premiered a song cycle they co-wrote, based on the Gamelan-inspired music of Benjamin Britten and Colin McPhee. Bartlett’s breathy, whispery vocals were nicely etched over the sound of two pianos. Muhly and Bartlett, each on a grand piano, sat back to back. Each would occasionally take a hand off of his own piano and perform on the other’s instrument.

Lisa Liu, Caroline Shaw, Nico Muhly, Thomas Bartlett, and Nadia Sirota | Credit: Reed Hutchinson

Muhly chose to end the evening with two of his drone-based pieces, in which the ensemble drew out a single note while soloists played aggressive rhythmic lines over them. The first piece featured Sirota, the violist, as soloist. Her agile playing, deep into the string, cut a clear sonic figure over the droning flute and cello beneath. The soloist on the second piece was the immensely capable violinist Lisa Liu. Her playing was sharp and in clear contrast to the smooth drone line below. Muhly intoned chords on the piano, bordering on the atonal at moments.

These two pieces were Muhly’s best of the night. While Muhly is known foremost as a composer, his piano abilities were on particular display. He plays a tactical and percussive piano, while still retaining clarity. It lends itself well to his intricate and bombastic compositions.

The evening was a sure success for Muhly. His varied choice of programming still retained the common thread of Glass’s influence. It made for a convincing narrative and the audience was enthusiastic. The level of playing was consistently strong.

Lisa Liu, Caroline Shaw, Nico Muhly, Alex Sopp, Nadia Sirota, and Patrick Belaga take a bow | Credit: Reed Hutchinson

Did you enjoy the article?

Sign up to our weekly newsletter to receive the latest articles every Tuesday