Primary tabs

West Bay Opera: A Microcosm Surprising and Grand

February 20, 2011

West Bay Opera

It's astonishing for a veteran of too many Turandot performances to keep count of to find one of the best in Palo Alto (pop. 60,000).

Yet, tiny West Bay Opera once again conquered a musical Goliath. At the Sunday matinee, José Luis Moscovich conducted a cohesive, balanced, and engaging performance, conveying the very heart of the work. The old warhorse pranced and raced around as a young filly.

Squeezed into a 77-year-old, 425-seat community theater, the WBO presented grand opera not in a grand manner, but delightfully and commandingly well.

Moscovich must have known, but he chose to ignore the impossible nature of his mission:

First, that Turandot is an opera spectacular, one that requires large forces, luxurious sets, and costumes on a big stage. It's hard enough just to imagine — much less to create — the Imperial Palace, the court, and the people of this "mythical place in the Far East" (what happened to "Peking"?) behind a proscenium opening 26 feet wide and 13 feet high.

Second, that it must have, at minimum, a good orchestra, a better chorus, some excellent soloists, and two exceptional singers for the top roles.

And third, and perhaps the biggest obstacle, is the opera's transparency. Most of the audience could hum along with the music (and some unfortunately always do), so if the performance is just a little bit off, the audience will know it.

Taking the last point first: almost nothing was off in the WBO presentation. During some of the big choral numbers (by two dozen singers representing both the court and the people), there were momentary glitches in the orchestra staying together, but Moscovich corrected that instantly.

And the orchestra, with concertmaster Kristina Anderson, numbering only 30 and squeezed into the smallest of makeshift pits, made Puccini sing, even without the singers. The clear, lyrical, passionate orchestral sound was to be treasured.

First and second violin sections of just three musicians each, the two cellos playing gorgeously, fine woodwinds, most of the brass most of the time made the score come alive and wash over the full house — all in perfect balance, while not overdoing it. For the opera's big moments, it would have been all too easy to try to bring down the ceiling, but Moscovich never once permitted loud, much less noisy, to substitute for forte.

This was true about the singers as well, something that must have taken some doing. David Gustafson, as Prince Calaf, has a big voice, he is also a heldentenor-in-the-making, and yet he was satisfied just singing beautifully, instead of joining the "look at me how loud I can be" school. With a bit more training as an actor, Gustafson's impressive presence — combined with his voice and mastery of the music — will make him a star.

It takes more than an hour for Turandot to sing her first note, but when Alexandra LoBianco launched into "In questa reggia," the wait was well rewarded. Musically and dramatically, the soprano presented a more complex character than the usual ice princess, she convinced listeners of a believable vulnerability under the armor. She sang the lyrical-to-heroic range with the ease and magnetism of a young Montserrat Caballe.

Will LoBianco achieve Caballe's artistry at the height of the great soprano's career? Time and luck will tell. But at this point she already has both — lyric and dramatic — fachs to a highly unusual degree.

She too managed to stay musical, even at the cost of taking the sound down a notch, even in the big climactic moments. It's a small theater — "singing small" is an absolutely necessity, especially as LoBianco and Gustafson both showed the reserve power in their command.

Adam Paul Lau's sonorous Timur and Liisa Dávila's simple, understated Liu made major contributions to the performance. Ping (Emmanuel Franco), Pang (Michael Desnoyers), and Pong (Michael Mendelsohn) sang so well they did not overstay their welcome during their big number (Act 2, Scene 1), which has some beautiful music that's not part of the hit parade, but runs about twice in length what it should be.

The small chorus, usually not one of the strengths of WBO, did exceptionally well. Moscovich blended voices and instruments in such a way that the opera's gestalt rose above individual performances, and the music hit in the chest, slightly left of center. Yes, this was a Turandot that got to you, instead of making the audience think, evaluate, and distance itself from the stage.

Peter Crompton's simple but impressive sets and Callie Floor's opulent costumes added to the overall impact of the production. David Cox's direction was smooth, with occasional slight missteps (such as the unending shtick of servants carrying chairs behind the fast-moving Ping-Pang-Pong trio wherever they went).

This David-conquers-Goliath production, especially its musical excellence, was no fluke. Moscovich has already managed such bold undertakings as La forza del destino, The Flying Dutchman, Pique DameMacbeth, and others — all surprisingly grand small productions.

It's a pleasant and important fantasy to imagine what WBO could do in a larger, better facility, with a front-of-house management that would rise above high-school auditorium values. Currently (and historically), basic logistical challenges such as getting the audience in and out of the theater utterly defeat the well-meaning but incompetent volunteer ushers.

Janos Gereben appreciates news tips, corrections, and words of encouragement at [email protected].


Much thanks for the terrific review! One correction - there are 29 of us in the chorus, which makes the chorus abut 25% larger than usual.


I loved your review and agree with it. My thoughts are that in a big house you feel more grandeur but in a small venue like Lucy Sterne the intimacy of the emotions between Calaf and Liu, Liu and the Father, Ping Pang Pang and of course Calaf and Turandot were felt more intensely. I realized how much of the emotion I don't feel when I see Turandot in a big house. For this reason, I think Turandot should be experienced (at least once) in an intimate setting. Counter intuitive...I know. Go WBO!

I am principal oboist and a 23-year veteran of the West Bay Opera orchestra. I don't remember if you've discussed this issue in your previous reviews, but I would like to point out to your readers that the orchestra does not sit together to play in our productions (nor in any earlier rehearsals) at the Lucie Stern Theater. The winds and brass play in the pit (actually meant to hold about 10-12 people comfortably rather than the 18-19 for our productions), the brass section sits and plays together in the basement below the pit, the harpist and keyboard player (when used) sit offstage in the wings and the percussion section plays from the paint room behind the stage. All sections other than the pit watch the conductor through TV monitors, are miked and receive sound from other sections through speaker monitors. Their sound is mixed and piped into the house and the pit through speakers. This is a highly unusual configuration due to the unfortunate size and logistics of the theater. Due to budget constraints, the company cannot afford to move to another theater with a better configuration. The orchestra and conductor simply put up with the problems and do the best they can. I find that many patrons are surprised and shocked to discover that the orchestra must play in this configuration, and yet do very well. Please credit the orchestra and conductor and our sound designer, Tod Nixon and his staff for doing the best job they can within the constraints of this theater.
Thank you.

I had seen "Turandot" twice before: at San Francisco Opera with Birgit Nielson and Leontyne Price (making her operatic debut as Liu), and the Metropolitan Opera in NYC. Both were magnificent productions. West Bay Opera fully matched the productions of the super companies. I was staggered by the singing, costumes, sets. Jose Moscovich is a treasure, huge ambition with talent to match. He brought off a production which will live in my memory always. Kudos to all the members of the cast and all those behind the scenes who contributed to this unforgettable performance.

I agree with everything in the review about this marvelous production, which I heard on opening night. However, i didn't like the comment about the ushers. I feel that was ungracious and uncalled for. They are community volunteers and in my experience, they have always been helpful and gracious.