Mozart the Clear Winner at S.F. Opera Don Giovanni

Janos Gereben on June 5, 2017
Erwin Schrott as Leporello and Ildebrando D'Arcangelo in the title role of Mozart's Don Giovanni | Credit: Cory Weaver/San Francisco Opera

It’s Prima la musica for the San Francisco Opera’s new production of Mozart’s 1787 Don Giovanni, opening for an eight-performance run today. That’s the answer in this case for the age-old question of which comes first, the music or the words.

What made the big, lasting impression today in the War Memorial was Marc Minkowski conducting the orchestra in a vital, energetic performance from the first downbeat through three hours of magnificent music. The man from Opéra National de Bordeaux is making his S.F. Opera debut, and may he return many times. Also on the musical front, but off the spotlight, was Robert Mollicone, playing recitative accompaniment on the fortepiano. Both Minkowski and Mollicone coddled the singers lovingly — a big group, many making their first appearance here.

Marc Minkowski | Credit: Dieter Nagl/AFP

The S.F. Opera’s marketing department is calling this a “reboot” of the last SFO production six years ago, with new projections and scenic adaptations by Tommi Brem, a German visual artist “whose work includes innovative projections and design work at the annual Burning Man festival.”

Stage director Jacopo Spirei and Brem promised a “new Don Giovanni that will look and feel decidedly different.” Brem’s contribution: 21 big (16 feet tall, 6 feet wide) polycarbonate plastic sheets — called mirrors, but not mirroring —used as occasional screens for ghostly images, including that of an incongruously smiling/sneering post-damnation Giovanni for the final curtain. During the performance, the plates go up and down, mostly without reason.

A scene from the end of Act II with some of the plates in use | Credit: Cory Weaver/San Francisco Opera

Don Giovanni is a great and difficult opera. It requires making a nasty antihero so seductive that his temporary success is believable, regardless of his dastardly treatment of men and, especially, of women.

San Francisco Opera has had more than a dozen productions of the opera since first presenting it in 1938 (when Fritz Reiner conducted, and Ezio Pinza sang the title role), and it’s still a work in progress as a drama. The original problem is with Lorenzo da Ponte’s libretto, which provides a series of scenes without character development: The second half of the opera (acts 3 and 4 together here) often requires the singers to stand and deliver — something that in Spirei’s direction becomes static in extremis.

Andrea Silvestrelli as the Commendatore and Ildebrando D'Arcangelo in the title role | Credit: Cory Weaver/San Francisco Opera

But back to what is good and occasionally even prima: the music, as sung. SFO General Director Matthew Shilvock addressed the audience before the performance to say that Ildebrando D’Arcangelo, making his San Francisco debut in the title role, was indisposed, but would perform. The cautionary note was unnecessary. The Italian bass-baritone was in fine fettle vocally and he delivered an athletic stage presence — his performance undiminished through the afternoon.

Another long-anticipated, local debut was of Uruguayan bass-baritone Erwin Schrott, himself an acclaimed Don Giovanni, but here appearing as Leporello, the put-upon servant. He looked and sounded Giovanni’s (and D’Arcangelo’s) equal in every way.

No slinking or cowering for this servant; Schrott stood tall, and produced a big, beautiful, effortless sound, soaring through the huge auditorium. Both D’Arcangelo and Schrott excelled in singing their big arias as integral parts of the work, instead of as standalone, applause-mining performances.

“Giovanni’s women” here are three very different singers: Puerto Rican soprano Ana Maria Martinez (last summer season’s Elisabetta in Don Carlo) is Donna Elvira, the seducer’s victim and nemesis. Canadian soprano Erin Wall makes her company debut as Donna Anna, daughter of the assassinated Commendatore-turned-stone-guest (Andrea Silvestrelli). Soprano Sarah Shafer (Rosetta in SFO’s 2015 Two Women) is Zerlina, the peasant girl, coveted by both Giovanni and her intended, Masetto (former Merola participant Michael Sumuel).

Sarah Shafer (center) as Zerlina | Credit: Cory Weaver/San Francisco Opera

Wall’s big voice (somewhat weakened toward the end of the opera) and Shafer’s unaffected, convincing acting stood out, while Martinez successfully combined vocal and stage presence, even when handicapped by the director’s misdirection of her long scene with Leporello disguised as Giovanni — offered as a farce, bordering on slapstick; there is lot more there there ... or should be.

Opera is Dramma per musica, (Drama for music), but the 2017 San Francisco “reboot” Don Giovanni is mostly great music, well played and sung, with some drama at the periphery, intersected by 21 large, polycarbonate plates. 

Did you enjoy the article?

Sign up to our weekly newsletter to receive the latest articles every Tuesday