Primary tabs

Romeo and Juliette Alive in Livermore

September 24, 2011

Livermore Valley Opera

Romeo and Juliette Livermore Valley OperaAt the start of its 20th anniversary season, Livermore Valley Opera deserves commendation and gratitude. Serving, as it were, as the greater Bay Area’s last outpost of the fine arts, the company serves up its twice-annual performances in the laudably live, verging on the bright, acoustic of the Bankhead Theatre. The location, positioned at the end of a large, spacious courtyard that forces evening operagoers to exit past any number of late-night partyers and bars that mix alcohol with jarring amplified music, could serve as a metaphor for a cultural oasis poised at the edge of the Wild, Wild Nuclear West (a.k.a., the abyss).

Following up last season’s excellent production of Madama Butterfly, the Livermore Valley Opera has ventured into more risky territory with a credible performance of Gounod’s infrequently mounted Roméo et Juliette. (The opera repeats on September 25, Oct.1, and Oct. 2.) The risks are spelled out in part in Stage Director Bill Murray’s “Insight” in the program guide. Murray acknowledges that Roméo et Juliette “represents the expected.” Noting that its plethora of duets are “static though beautiful,” he admits that Gounod’s Faust “succeeds where Roméo et Juliette fails: better character definition and a more organic development of story.” All of which is to say that it was up to the singers, conductor, director, and production to make a less than riveting five act opera, known principally for two wonderful arias, into something worth sitting through.

Soprano Success

The Wedding Scene: Christie Hageman as Juliette and Christian Reinart as RomeoLVO scored big by engaging soprano Christie Hageman, Miss Montana 2006, as Juliette. Once her voice warmed up, Hageman displayed an estimably large and well-focused instrument with a lovely timbre, perfect trill, and soaring top. Though her famous Act 1 Waltz Song, which came before her voice had settled in, lacked buoyancy — conductor Alex Katsman’s plodding tempo did not help — her portrayal grew increasingly secure and tender as the act progressed. Hageman’s lovely bearing and sympathetic countenance could serve as a model of French grace and restraint.

More problematic was tenor Christian Reinert’s Roméo. A tall, handsome man with a big dramatic voice, Reinert displayed a dismaying tendency to swell into notes after initially hitting them softly. This might not have been a problem had his voice been steady and even, but in this performance it was not. As the voice opened, the vibrato widened and the tonal balance shifted markedly. Far too many single notes sounded like they were actually two, repeated at roughly the same pitch. Needless to say, this took a major toll on his legato. As admirable as was Reinert’s attempt to soften on the final note of his one famous aria, “Ah, lève toi soleil,” the performance and most of his scenes fell flat.

Mercutio and TibaltPart of this was due to his bearing. Although the program bio does not say that Reinert trained in ballet, his dismaying tendency to spend too much of his time standing perfectly erect and virtually still with his feet turned out and arms hanging passively at his side did not help animate the opera. His best scene, which aroused a fair share of tittering in the audience, found him stripped to the waist, leaning over a clothed Juliette in what passed for post-coital passion. Was director Murray unable to do anything more with him?

Thankfully, the other cast members — Michelle Rice (Gertrude), Ernest Alvarez (Tybalt), Nikolas Nackley (Grégorio), Roberto Perlas Gomez (a wonderfully animated Mercutio), Michael Jankosky (Benvolio), Jennifer Panara (a delightful Stéphano), Julio Ferrara (Duke of Verona), Torlef Borsting (Count Paris), and Nicholas Shelton (a sonorous Frère Laurent) — all sang well and with considerable volume. The chorus, on the other hand, was a bit ragged.

Despite the efforts of Fight Director Carla Pantoja, fight scenes and interactions were sometimes stilted, but they were as well in San Francisco Opera’s Heart of a Soldier. Hats off to Murray for taking advantage of Alvarez’s large abdomen to have him bump the much shorter and slighter Gomez around before killing him.

Where Are the Lights?

Never once in the production did the stage lights come up full, not even in what passed as daylight. Far too often, singers were left in semi-darkness or worse, without a spot to light their features. Key scenes and arias went by without the ability to clearly make out facial expressions. This did not help the opera’s admittedly arrested character development.

I suppose Light Designer Kevin Bautch chose to bathe everyone in funereal yellow light at the Act 1 opening masked ball in order to simulate candlelight, but the results completely washed out the colors in Hannah Phillips-Ryan’s costumes. Phillips-Ryan clearly put a huge amount of effort and imagination into clothing everyone differently, and enhancing ballgoers’ appearances with some delightful accessories. What a shame that her efforts could not be fully appreciated.

Katsman’s orchestra played well, producing luminous tone in interludes. How much of the lack of energy in duets and some solo numbers was due to singers’ limitations, conducting, directorial lapses, or lighting is open to conjecture.

Jason Victor Serinus is a music critic, professional whistler, and lecturer on classical vocal recordings. His credits includes Seattle Times, Listen, Opera News, Opera Now, American Record Guide, Stereophile, Classical Voice North America, Carnegie Hall Playbill, Gramophone, San Francisco Magazine, Stanford Live, Bay Area Reporter, San Francisco Examiner, AudioStream, and California Magazine.


Mr. Serinus, thank you for taking the time to review us. I never thought LVO would be compared to SFO in the same article. As a smaller, regional opera company we have struggled for this kind of serious media attention.

We endeavor to bring quality to this art form on our small stage and will continue to strive for artistic excellence, even if it means taking some artistic risks.

Thanks again for putting on the page as an integral part of SF Bay Area opera. These talented singers have to get their start somewhere. We are lucky to be able to tap into the large pool of talent attracted to this region by a major house.

Teri Tith
Vice President
Livermore Valley Opera

I found LVO's Romeo et Juliette quite enjoyable and, given their status as a small regional company, admirably done. The sets (clearly within their budget which is praiseworthy in itself) were very effective, especially the intimately-scaled abbey scene. But I have to admit I was also puzzled by the excessive "mood" lighting -- a few spots, especially during the opening scenes, would have made a world of difference.

As the photographer of the above images, I certainly agree that the lighting was dark. It is good that I have a rather new digital camera with high ISO's. But all images required a good deal of manipulation in PhotoShop to be presentable.

That said, The voices were thrilling. I loved the costumes. The fight scenes were remarkable and riveting.

>a metaphor for a cultural oasis poised at the edge of the Wild, Wild Nuclear West
>(a.k.a., the abyss).

It's both irrelevant and unprofessional to beat that particular political drum in an opera review, in my opinion.

By the way, there should be no comma after "a.k.a."

The production was wonderful. Everything an opera should be. Great singing, beautiful sets, lovely costumes and good work backstage. We enjoyed every note and every scene change. Thank you LVO

The cast was just what one hopes for ... older voices might have more technical maturity, but it's thrilling to have an appropriately young, vibrant Romeo and Juliette bring new life to these roles.

While I very much enjoyed the performance on Saturday, I must confess that agree with much of the reviewer's assessment of the cast. While Ms. Hageman and the supporting cast's singing was very fine, I was underwhelmed by Mr. Reinert's Romeo. Physically, his performance was stiff and virtually devoid of emotional expression, and I found his singing quite labored and unpleasant at times (save the fairly well-executed pianissimo at the end of his aria). Perhaps he was feeling a bit "off" that night.

Very accurate review. Reinart was a singing corpse. The problem was that he was trying to sound far larger and dramatic than I think his voice really was.
The lighting was really dark too. I never fully saw Romeo's face until the third act.